Emma-Jean Lazarus Fell Out of a Tree

Starred review from February 5, 2007
Through a compelling third-person narrative, first novelist Tarshis completely inhabits the character of an eccentric seventh-grader who will quickly win over readers. Emma-Jean Lazarus misses her father, who died two years ago and from whom she inherited an analytical mind. She does not always understand her "often irrational" peers and finds their lives "messy." She "thus made it her habit to keep herself separate, to observe from afar." One day, however, she discovers kind, sensitive Colleen in the girls' bathroom and decides to come to her aid. (The narrative occasionally shifts to Colleen's perspective, offering insight into how the heroine comes across to her classmates.) Emma-Jean takes her cue from the philosophy of Jules Henri Poincaré (a French mathematician whom her late father revered), who believed that "even the most complex problems could be solved through a process of creative thinking." Her well-intentioned efforts with Colleen and with others don't always hit their mark, but this slightly socially awkward, big-hearted outsider learns from her experiences. Other fully realized characters who show compassion and understanding to Emma-Jean include her mother, a wise and kind custodian, her teacher and especially Vikram, a doctoral student and the Lazaruses' boarder, who takes on a special significance to both mother and daughter. Readers will cheer on Emma-Jean as she begins to see more clearly and enter more fully the world around her, messiness and all. Ages 8-up.

October 1, 2007
Gr 5-8-Emma-Jean Lazarus is like no other middle-school girl you have ever met. She doesn't do messy friendships. She doesn't waste a thought on boys. Most astonishing of all, she doesn't care what her peers think about her. So of course, Emma-Jean Lazarus is the freak of William Gladstone Middle School. She takes after her deceased father, a mathematical wizard, and his heroFrench mathematician Jules Henri Poincare. Emma-Jean believes "even the most complex problems could be solved through a process of creative thinking." When Emma-Jean discovers Colleen sobbing in the girl's restroom over an encounter with the school's "female alpha chimp," she steps in, uses the power of logic, and solves her classmate's problem. Bolstered by her success, Emma-Jean looks around for other people to assist. The results are disastrous. Real lifeand real emotionsare simply too complex. Emma-Jean moves from being the observer to being involved. As Poincare said, "It is by logic that we prove, but it is in our hearts that we discover life's possibilities." In her first novel (Dial, 2007), Lauren Tarshis has created an original character who will delight youngsters. Narrator Mamie Gummer, daughter of Meryl Streep, delivers a wonderfully nuanced performance. Her Emma-Jean is Rainman-like in voice, and adults might ponder the possibility of Emma-Jean having a touch of autism. Younger listeners will simply listen and relish this wonderfully crafted story. Booktalking will be necessary to overcome the dreadful cover art. A superb addition to audiobook collections.Tricia Melgaard, Centennial Middle School, Broken Arrow, OK

Copyright 2007 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

Starred review from April 13, 2009
Tarshis proves she “gets” adolescent female friendships (not to mention seventh grade) in this funny and empathetic follow-up to Emma-Jean Lazarus Fell Out of a Tree
. For the first time, the intensely analytical Emma-Jean has friends among her peers (as she refers to them) and, like them, she is preoccupied with the girl-invite Spring Fling. Emma-Jean considers asking basketball star Will, though they have little in common—he's been kind to her and causes a “fluttering of her heart.” But she ends up sorting out the dance-related woes of fragile Colleen (whose point of view is explored in certain chapters). Fans of the first book will be pleased that the deadpan narration (“as a single cell can reveal the DNA code of an entire organism, the look in Kaitlin's eyes told Emma-Jean everything she needed to know”) and Emma-Jean's observations are as amusing as ever. (“Adolescent males engage in conspicuous displays to attract the attention of females,” is her explanation of cafeteria boisterousness.) Her blossoming appreciation for emotions that logic can't explain, sympathetic supporting characters and an uplifting finale will warm hearts. Ages 10–14.